Introduction
Caroline Healey Dall’s scrapbook and drawings by Sarah Clarke, from the collections of the Boston Athenaeum. Photographs by Gosia Sklodowska and Alice de Galzain.
By Phyllis Cole, Gosia Sklodowska, and Ulrike Wagner
Christopher Cranch's Transparent Eyeball, perhaps the most recognizable visual emblem of American Transcendentalism, has come to capture something of the movement's enduring appeal: its aspiration toward a more expansive vision of the self in the world. The caricature depicts a disproportionately large eye in place of a stick figure's head, surveying the landscape in a playful parody of Emerson’s famous description of becoming “a transparent eyeball,” in his first major published work, Nature (1836). The drawing belongs to a remarkable collection of Cranch's caricatures, meticulously preserved in the archives of Harvard's Houghton Library. Yet one drawing is missing from the set. Known only through later recollections, the image offers a rather different picture of the movement and the figures who shaped it.
In her 1883 biography of Margaret Fuller, Julia Ward Howe recalled that Cranch’s caricature of The Dial presented Fuller, in her role as the journal’s editor and the movement’s guiding force, “as a Minerva, driving a team of the new illuminati.”[1] George Willis Cooke, writing his historical introduction to The Dial, first published in 1902, also remembered the drawing, describing it as “the cleverest” of Cranch’s sketches. In Cooke’s recollection, Emerson rides behind Fuller in the ca riage as her passenger.[2] Although the caricature itself appears to have been lost, these two accounts give us a glimpse of a striking scene: a woman at the reins of the Transcendentalist movement.
Manuscripts and drawings disappear. They are misplaced, dispersed, or lost as they pass from one owner to another, and we do not know what became of Cranch's Fuller-as- Minerva caricature. Yet, although this satirical image of the Transcendentalists is nowhere to be found, it still tells us something about how contemporaries perceived the movement: at the center of the scene is a woman steering a carriage propelled by contributors to America’s leading cultural movement, with its presumed leader, Emerson, taking a back seat. Like the drawing itself, the women driving Transcendentalism have faded into the background or been overshadowed by other figures and versions of how the movement began and how it is remembered. The present project aims to bring some of them back to our awareness.
In Toward a Female Genealogy of Transcendentalism (2014), Jana Argersinger and Phyllis Cole published research on the women of the movement which leaves no doubt that they played crucial roles in the movement, building its foundations and determining its direction as writers, critics, translators, poets, educators, and visionary reformers. Leading with the word “Toward,” the editors’ intent was not to be definitive or final, but to open a new direction of study, responding to recent decades’ interest in both a classic movement in American literature and a broader recovery of women’s lost voices. Indeed, the introduction to their collection ended by inviting readers to “extend the conversation.”[3] Our present collection is a response to that invitation, undertaken as part of the Center for Study of World Religions' “Transcendentalism Initiative” (2026–27), an ongoing symposium intended to broaden the movement’s reach and contemporary relevance.
Expanding on the previous volume, we carry the 2014 project of “archaeology and reinterpretation” further by delving into rarely explored archives for new perspectives on women’s writing, now supported by extended excerpts from relevant texts.[4] As in the earlier project, we extend our reach beyond the pre-Civil War decades to the end of the century, when individuals and institutions flourished under this movement’s influence. A common theme is the importance of reading and of readers becoming writers, whether in the private settings of letter and diary or in published work.
Though Transcendentalism has traditionally been construed as an expression of solitude and “self-reliance,” we emphasize the importance of conversation, friendship, and group meeting. The tradition in question is not simply a vertical descent across time from one woman to another, but a network that extends both laterally and vertically. Building on this methodological foundation, we consider letters, diaries, reading circles, and networks of friendship and intellectual collaboration as central sites of Transcendentalist activity. As Cole and Argersinger show, the practices of reading, writing, discussion, and community formation fostered through the circulation of such materials were crucial to the education of those traditionally excluded from universities and other institutions that conferred intellectual authority and academic credentials.
In bringing together nearly twenty contributors here, however, we do more than continue to recover new archival material, neglected forms of writing, and the female voices shaping the period. The research and the primary documents in this new collection show from a wide range of perspectives that recovering these women’s intellectual activity also means uncovering some of the very foundations from which our own scholarship in the humanities developed. As John Guillory’s recent historical account of the emergence of literary study as an academic discipline demonstrates, literature once encompassed a far broader range of writing and reading practices than the works that would eventually become the objects of specialized research and literary canons.[5] In the era of the Transcendentalists, literature and criticism flourished largely outside the university, whose curriculum remained dominated by classical languages and theology.[6] Thus, intellectual activities that appear peripheral to professionalized literary study today—including public lectures, private and periodical writing, sociability, and intellectual exchange—were central to literary culture and social reform.
At a time when academic writing is increasingly specialized, less accessible to the wider reading public, and struggling to maintain relevance, the Transcendentalist women offer us a window into a different intellectual culture, one that preceded the division of knowledge into specialized fields. Their engagement with philosophy, poetry, science, theological scholarship, and spirituality was inseparable from the most pressing concerns of their generation: women's equality, abolitionism, and religious and educational reform.
Although the era in which literary thought circulated without competition from electronic media has long since passed, we invite readers to consider how these women’s intellectual practices and social activities might resonate with us today. In thinking about the role of reading today, we ask what we can learn from a culture in which reading was a source of pleasure and self-cultivation, a means of building networks across borders, and a bridge to engage with social concerns.
We began this introduction with a lost image, and it seems fitting to conclude with images and words that survived through an extraordinary act of friendship, attention, and care. Caroline Healey Dall’s “Dante Scrapbook” preserved materials capturing her artist friend Sarah Clarke’s life-long intellectual and artistic aspirations: articles, etchings, and sketches toward Clarke's unrealized volume on the life of Dante. “[...] When Miss Clarke saw this book as nearly completed she said, ‘This is the only testimonial to a Great Work undertaken, whose present fate I do not know. Will you for my sake, when I am gone, give this to the Boston Athenaeum? There, if anywhere in the world there may hereafter be some who will care for it for my sake.’"[7]
Clarke’s appeal “for my sake” and Dall’s obedience to Clarke's request speak to their generation’s desire to be remembered and recognized for what they did. Their preservation efforts, as well as the global prominence of Cranch’s Eyeball compared to his lost drawing of a woman leading the movement, also remind us how much women’s intellectual history has depended on precisely such acts of attention and care: the collection, preservation, circulation, and continued discussion and citation of materials that would otherwise disappear. We place our scholarship within this genealogy of networks of relationship and care. We take up the conversation for Clarke’s and Dall’s sake, and for all the women whose lives and works this collection brings together. Their intellectual legacies depend on new generations of readers to engage with their writings, amplify their voices, and bring their ideas into conversation with the questions of our time.
Notes
[1] “[...] having already somewhat the position of a ‘come-outer,’ Margaret was naturally supposed to be in entire sympathy with the Transcendentalists. This supposition was strengthened by her assuming the editorship of the ‘Dial,’ and Christopher Cranch, in caricaturing it, represented her as a Minerva driving a team of the new illuminati.” Julia Ward Howe, Margaret Fuller (Marchesa Ossoli) (1883), Project Gutenberg eBook no. 32511, released May 24, 2010, accessed November 16, 2026, https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/32511
[2] “[...] Cranch represented Margaret Fuller as driving a carriage, and Emerson as riding behind her. The editors are presented as saying: "Our Dial shows the march of light O'er forests, hills, and meadows." George Willis Cooke, An Historical and Biographical Introduction to Accompany the Dial (New York: Russell & Russell, 1961), 174.
[3] Phyllis Cole and Jana Argersinger, “Introduction,” in Toward a Female Genealogy of Transcendentalism (Athens: University of Georgia Press, 2014), 25.
[4] Ibid., 7.
[5] John Guillory, Professing Critisicm. Essays on the Organization of Literary Study (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2022), 44–78, 199–223.
[6] Ibid., 125–64.
[7] Caroline Healey Dall continues the letter with “I am now eighty-five years old, and I dare not trust the fulfilment of my promise, to anyone else. Precious in my sight, it should surely be dear to the children of those who have loved and remembered the sister of James Freeman Clarke.” Caroline Healey Dall, The Caroline Dall Dante Scrapbook, May 1907, unpublished manuscript, Boston Athenaeum.