Paratechnologies and Agency 

Marleen Thaler, Postdoctoral Research Fellow, University of Graz (Austria) | Edited by Aaron Michael Ullrey 

 

Since the industrial era, technological innovation has rationalized production and circulation by reducing costs and standardizing procedures. This economic rationalization casts inherited traditions and rituals as inefficient or unnecessary, consequently bringing about a supposedly “disenchanted” modernity that is marked by a break from a religious, magical, or irrational past. Disenchantment, in this rationalized view, names the shift in the order of the world from being determined by mysterious incalculable agents to the world being explainable and able to be governed by calculable agents. Technology assumes a key role in such assumptions, in as much as it has often been treated as emblematic of a disenchanted modernity.

Photo of Mesmer’s baquet
Mesmer’s baquet (public domain)

Regarding technology, the assumed shift from enchanted to disenchanted has never happened, for people perpetually re-enchant technology by endowing technological devices with nonhuman or superhuman agency; this, in turn, reconfigures religious concepts, introduces new practices, and sacralizes emerging technologies. The relation between technology and religion is continually renegotiated, oscillating between technology as a human tool for mastering nature and technology as a force mastering us. 

At the core of these negotiations lies the problem of agency in two linked senses: the ways that human actors attribute power and responsibility to technology and the ways that human control is reconfigured—how it is lost or gained through encountering and interacting with technologies. Anxieties about losing agency but also hopes for regaining control manifest in technophobia and technophilia, dual sides of what I call “agency panic.” Current discussions about AI exemplify technophobia while at the same time raising technophilic hopes. But agency panic is not new. 

Reich’s orgone accumulator (1950s)
Reich’s orgone accumulator (1950s) (public domain)

Questions about power and agentic control, arising from the enchantment of technologies by associating them with nonhuman or superhuman agents, strikingly manifest in paratechnologies, which are “special” and often marginalized technological devices imbued with religious meanings. Examples of paratechnological devices include healing devices, such as Franz A. Mesmer’s baquet and Wilhelm Reich’s orgone accumulator, and communication apparatuses, such as spirit telegraphs and “extraterrestrial” radios. These paratechnologies are framed as restoring personal efficacy or opening channels to other agents; while also triggering fears about diminished self-control.

Mesmer and Reich created and deployed devices for subtle-energy therapy and healing. Mesmer’s late eighteenth-century baquet is a wooden, tub-like device filled with fragments of glass, gravel, and magnetized water. Iron rods linked several patients to the baquet, allowing them to receive animal magnetic therapy at the same time. While widely considered a symbol of progress, attributing agency to the device fueled technophobic reactions by stoking fears about loss of control. Intended to draw in and concentrate what he called “orgone energy,” which is a cosmic and all-pervading life force, Reich’s mid-twentieth century orgone accumulator was a person-sized, enclosed box made of alternating layers of organic material and metal. The orgone accumulator drew upon a proposed link between orgone, sexuality, and vitality to restore physical and spiritual vitality and sexual autonomy; the attributed agency of the device is claimed to impart technophilic self‑empowerment but on the grounds of disputed moral and health claims, inspiring technophobia.  

Image of A “spiritoscope” – an adapted spirit communication device
A “spiritoscope” – an adapted spirit communication device, mid-18th century (Robert Hare (1855) Experimental Investigation of the Spirit Manifestations. New York: Partridge & Brittan)

Nineteenth-century spirit telegraphs and twentieth-century extraterrestrial radios promise contact and communication with unverifiable non-human entities who are made approachable through technological devices. Spiritualists cast emerging communication technologies as conduits to the dead, and used telegraph-like apparatuses that produced clicks, which they attributed to spirits, and they used Morse-code as a cipher to convey guidance from spirits. Agency is centered on mediation and authentication of these spirit messages, but agency panic arose from anxieties over deception by mediums. Post-war contactees adapted short-wave radio transceivers as “extraterrestrial” communication devices that conveyed voices, tones, and coded signals from presumed extraterrestrial superior intelligences. These modified radio sets augment human destiny through extraterrestrial contact, but reactions oscillated between positive support of human initiative and fear about heteronomous interference in human affairs. Technophilia and technophobia abound. 

Philips AE3650 portable shortwave receiver
Philips AE3650 portable shortwave receiver, exemplifying the use of technology for “extraterrestrial” communication. © Raimond Spekking / CC BY-SA 4.0 (via Wikimedia Commons), Philips AE 3650-00-48258, CC BY-SA 4.0

Religious ideas shape technological imaginaries that inspire the creation, use, and propagation of epistemically marginalized paratechnologies. Some employ intangible powers to expand vitality and longevity; others are ostensibly secular devices endowed with the ability to deliver messages and gain information from disembodied agents. Far from technology inspiring the rationalized disenchantment of the world, emerging technologies sacralize and re-enchant the modern world.  

The current deluge of claims about AI agency, sentience, and even its purported ability to interact with non-human agencies such as magnetic powers, spirits, and UAPs overlaps with the historical excitement and anxiety about paratechnologies. Such conversations reveal and reshape religious concepts like the nature of being, our relationship to non-human spiritual agencies, and the role of superhuman agents in rituals. We are in the midst of another agency panic, but the past has shown that this is an opportunity to reconsider the nature of human control and even the nature of the divine. 

 

This Research Reflection is part of an ongoing series spotlighting the academic study of religions. 

Marleen Thaler

Marleen Thaler is a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Graz and a research and teaching fellow at the University of Vienna. Previously, she was a research fellow at ETH Zurich (2022), UC Riverside (2022), and UC Santa Barbara (2023). Marleen is the author of the forthcoming book Albion’s Sage for the New Age (Equinox, 2026) and co-edited Subtle Energies in Therapy, Spirituality, Arts, and Politics (Brill, 2025). Her main research interests include the transformation of religion, the modern history of yoga, and religion and technology.

photo of Marleen Thaler